« The most annoying profile New York magazine has ever published and that's saying something | Main | Fast food »
07/26/2005
Glum, numb, gum
Throughout my long and checkered reproductive career, I've stoically endured some pretty significant pain. The radioactive dye of an HSG sent me scrabbling backwards toward the end of the table, making it necessary for a nurse to hold me by the shoulders lest I make good my frantic escape. The protracted passing of an ectopic mass made me see stars, moons, a quasar or two, and the ghostly smirking specter of Carl Sagan, God damn his turtlenecked soul. And the searing epigastric pain of HELLP made me suspect I was pretty darn close to dying.
Um.
Anyway, I'm no stranger to pain, and I tend to cope with it well (if "well" means "biting my tongue clean through into two neat meaty planks while remaining perfectly still and outwardly calm"). This fortitude does not, however, extend to mouth pain. I quail even to think of that pointy dental tool you know the one, the one the dentist sinks into your gums as she records the depth of the pus-leaking corruption therein.
You know, that pointy thing.
I hate going to the dentist, and I put it off as long as I possibly can. I fall into a funk for days before any appointment, and I always ask that I be given some sort of sedative/anesthetic cocktail before even undergoing the bite-wing X-rays (a perfectly reasonable request that is always summarily refused). But overall, I'm lucky: thanks to heredity and no great interest in sweets, I have good teeth and decent gums. I can generally get away with missing a cleaning or two. Or many, many more than that.
And so it happened that I was at the dentist last week for an introductory visit after quite some time without a checkup. The dentist gave me a tissue to clutch in my sweaty, sweaty palms, mounted a set of goggles on her face that made her look like an giant, angry fly about to deposit a clump of larvae in my mouth, and started in.
As she worked, she asked questions, and I responded as best I could with that pointy thing poised to stab me in the uvula if she didn't like my answers. She almost gaffed my tonsils when I told her about Charlie: she sees Paul very frequently, knows his teeth more intimately than I do, yet did not know we have a son.
That was all the encouragement she needed. She perched near the arm of my chair, staring soulfully into my gullet with her fly goggles, and talked. And talked. And talked. About gum, of all things.
It turns out that those clever Europeans have known for years that if the parents of an infant chew gum containing the sweetener xylitol starting when the baby is six months of age, that infant is then at significantly reduced risk for tooth decay. How does it work? Well, xylitol apparently neutralizes the oral bacteria that cause tooth decay, keeping a mother from transmitting them via big, wet slobbery tongue kisses yes, I do, and what of it? and preventing her baby's mouth from getting colonized by cariogenic bacteria.
This salutary effect persists for at least six years past the, ah, therapeutic gum-chewing window.
I told my mother about this after my appointment, pausing in my enthusiastic chewing only long enough to get the words out intelligibly, spraying minty fresh saliva all over the telephone receiver, and she scoffed. "Suuuure it works. And did she also offer to sell you a bridge?"
What can I say? I believe our dentist, and I believe the studies, and I believe I'll have another stick of gum, thanks.
That said, I'm pretty sure when it comes to her diagnosis concerning my wisdom teeth, she's a goddamn fly-faced uvula-spearing larva-leaving liar.
Posted by Julie at 10:49 PM in I've learned a lot...but I'm not sure it's worth it. | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834518e0569e200d834844e5769e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Glum, numb, gum:
Comments (47)
oooh, ooh I'm first? Craziness! I don't even have anything to say other that, whoops, my son will have dental rot from all my oedipal tonsil hockey, but I'll start chewing now for the 5 mos old little girl, although I probably won't make out with her as much.
Posted by: katharine at Jul 26, 2005 10:57:22 PM
I saw "dentist" and that's as far as I'll read, if it's all the same to you. The last time I went to the dentist, it was to have my (severely impacted) wisdom teeth out. I'll only say that he omitted to put anaesthetic on the left hand side of my mouth/jaw (whatever), and began to yank the bloody things out despite. Needless to say, I screamed right through the IV administered valium. Whoever called it "conscious sedation" and said "you won't remember a thing" OBVIOUSLY didn't have a dentist attempt to pull THEIR wisdom teeth without any anaesthetic!!
Posted by: Simonne at Jul 26, 2005 10:58:36 PM
Crap. I thought I was going to be first :-)
Posted by: Simonne at Jul 26, 2005 10:59:17 PM
I am hurt. All my whining-between-needles about how I haven't slept because the boy was keeping me awake apparently passed through one million-candlepower-halogen-light-supporting ear and out the other. Or maybe I just wasn't enunciating very well with three cotton rolls, two hands, a jet-wash-equipped power drill and some kind of clamp-on medieval torture device in my mouth.
Posted by: paul at Jul 26, 2005 11:01:10 PM
HILARIOUS! I've known about the xylitol thing for YEARS, because in college the guy I lived with for four years was the son of the Finnish researcher who initiated the xylitol-in-gum-and-candy studies back in the seventies. His name is Kauko Makinen..... google him. An intensely brilliant, kind, and wonderful person who just can't seem to retire. He's a biochemist who had his studies in Belize and Estonia funded by the University of Michigan Dental School for years. I remember telling MY dentist about the xylitol thing back in the early nineties and he thought I was NUTS. Then FINALLY last year at his office I noticed all the literature he had posted on the walls about the stuff. The US is pretty slow to get on the bus for A LOT of things; a day late and a dollar short. For ten years I was getting all the xylitol laced foodstuffs and toothpaste I wanted for FREE. Incidentally I was in Finland last summer for a month to visit my old boyfriend and his parents, his dad is now helping China get on board with the xylitol thing. A great man, I'm proud to know him!
I share with you the dental phobia, and I thank All that is Holy for my stellar dental genes....
Posted by: Jennifer at Jul 26, 2005 11:27:53 PM
OK, now brands please?
Warming up jaws.
Posted by: Menita at Jul 26, 2005 11:53:45 PM
Amen and pass the Xylitol. Does it have an effect in utero?
*has bizarre vision of tongue somehow ending up inside own uterus*
Posted by: Maria at Jul 27, 2005 1:00:44 AM
What an interesting study! I have an "oral fixation", if you will, and ♥ chewing gum! Even with braces on for the past 6 years... I've chewed consistently and never had a problem.
Thanks for the interesting info! :)
Posted by: Firebrand at Jul 27, 2005 1:43:38 AM
Well, we do eat xilitol chewinggum because of the good it is to ourt teeth (I think this started 10 years ago! But I doubt that you can find a docter or dentist who will advise on giving it to babies ;-)
Mijk (in Europe!)
Posted by: mijk42 at Jul 27, 2005 5:09:32 AM
How weird. I guess this means I'm going to have to start chewing gum. I hate chewing gum. My husband is a European and always has his xlyitol infested gum in his mouth, swearing it keeps his mouth clean. Maybe he's right, though he has to have three fillings on Thursday and I haven't had a filling since I was 12.
Posted by: Carrie at Jul 27, 2005 5:35:00 AM
Heh. How timely. My wisdom teeth will be removed in 2 days. Grrr.
Interesting about the gum, though.
Posted by: Evil Stepmother at Jul 27, 2005 7:05:48 AM
About your previous post - a touch of Kipling may be in order here (it's from his poem "The Mary Gloster"):
"They copied all they could follow, but they couldn't copy my mind,
And I left 'em sweating and stealing a year and a half behind."
Let 'em sweat.
Posted by: Menita at Jul 27, 2005 7:21:47 AM
Assvice alert. This is coming from a woman who just had her wisdom teeth out last month: you get yourself sedated. I remember saying that I was terrified, and then they put the needle in my arm. What seemed like two seconds later, I was laughing hysterically as I staggered to the recovery room. "There are holes in my mouth! HAHAHA!"
Posted by: RosebudPeas at Jul 27, 2005 8:58:26 AM
I have the World's Most Sarcastic Dentist.
There is a new woman at his front desk every time I go because he is so snarky to every one I don't think the poor dears can handle it for more than 6 months. It is hard to believe anything he says.
But he did say he was impressed that in spite of the fact that I hadn't had my teeth cleaned in 10 years and I NEVER floss, I hardly had any placque and nary a cavity. But then he attributed it all not to my dedicated 3-4 times a day brushing (I dunno, it just feels good....) but to the fact that I have "good spit" that has the ability to neutralize bad bacteria. He said it is genetic.
And he will laugh hysterically as I did at the "goddamn fly-faced uvula-spearing larva-leaving liar" comment. You are a poet.
Posted by: wheelomatic at Jul 27, 2005 9:32:59 AM
Dang, I'm not allowed to chew gum. Dentist orders--tmj. And my older kid just learned how to do it without swallowing. How can a 6 month old coordinate gum?
Posted by: Running2Ks at Jul 27, 2005 11:04:44 AM
When I was in college I had to have all four of my wisdom teeth pulled. The dentist, fooled by the x-rays, said that it would be an easy proceedure and I drove myself there. And back home again. And then didn't get out of bed for a week. The x-rays lied.
I will admit tho, that it felt better in the long run not to have those teeth in my mouth.
Posted by: Nancy at Jul 27, 2005 11:08:01 AM
Hey, did you know that the military is now including that gum in their MREs (meal kits)? Turns out they too discovered the benefits of gum with that particular ingredient. A huge percentage of those coming home from the desert had tooth decay (imagine that! You're not guaranteed a shower much less time to brush your teeth), so they've started including that gum to prevent it.
And this is ironic because I was just at the dentist yesterday after an absence that was WAY too long. I still need my blasted wisdom teeth pulled, but this whole pregnancy thing is buying me some time.
Posted by: Drama Queen at Jul 27, 2005 11:14:01 AM
I hate the dentist too, but I hate gum and mint more.
So, I'll just keeping getting the drugs to calm me down and skip the gum.
BTW - when I had all my fillings replaced, we lost count after 14 needles to freeze one side of my mouth.
Posted by: Scully at Jul 27, 2005 12:11:54 PM
How can a 6 month old coordinate gum?
No, no, the baby doesn't chew gum! The parents do!
Posted by: Julie at Jul 27, 2005 12:22:56 PM
You realize it's not really the kisses that transmit the germs so much as the spit-baths, right? Just so we're clear.
Posted by: Bec at Jul 27, 2005 1:11:35 PM
So you mean I shouldn't be licking him all over like a cat?
But the folds of his neck are so cheesy!
Posted by: Julie at Jul 27, 2005 1:32:11 PM
Yes, yes, I am a big fan of xylitol gum!--enough so to poke my head up out of my lurker's burrow. My Finnish sister-in-law introduced me to the stuff, and then an M.D. enthused about it too. I am chewing on a piece right now!
"Xylichew" is the name of one brand available in the states. (They have a fruity flavor I like.) Google for sources, or check local health-food-type stores. I ordered some through an online vendor.
Incidentally, I remember reading that xylitol gum use has also been linked to lower rates of ear infections in older children.
Posted by: anonymous mostly-lurker at Jul 27, 2005 3:22:20 PM
I only go to the dentist if I'm in pain first. Otherwise, I'm "allergic" to the dentist. Dentist=Pain and Pain=Dentist. It's a vicious cycle for me.
Posted by: Amy Steier at Jul 27, 2005 4:36:22 PM
I loved the new "Flash thingy" at the Blog's headline...
Posted by: Anette at Jul 27, 2005 8:35:57 PM
My dentist gives me Valium beforehand, and will shoot me up with Novacaine before a simple cleaning, becuase I am a panicky freak and punched him in the gut once. I like my dentist and schedule my appointments for my vacations home.
Does BubbleYum contain the specific cavity-preventative sweetner? Would it work if you simply let the child chew gum? Six months sounds pretty good...
I find the new bar a little depressing, but the animation is cute.
Posted by: BeckaJo at Jul 27, 2005 8:50:18 PM
Oh the sperm! LMAO! How true, yet ironic, and still humorous. Love it. Hope no one can steal it.
Also, dentist may be right, I have run across a crap ton of research articles about the gum and cavities in kids. It all points to the gum being of some benifit. Oh well, can't hurt, might help--also an excuse to blow some bubbles.
Posted by: Meganann at Jul 27, 2005 8:54:02 PM
love the sperm and egg graphic!!!!!!!
Posted by: VHMPrincess at Jul 27, 2005 8:54:19 PM
If I decided to email you about your awesome new graphic, I would say, with both maturity and poise:
"OMG JULIE IT r0x0rs!"
Posted by: Jen at Jul 27, 2005 9:07:56 PM
LMAO at the new egg/sperm graphic... sound effects particularly amusing...hope no one can steal it!
Posted by: shari at Jul 27, 2005 9:56:42 PM
Love the new layout. An HPT pee stick with a faint second line on it is not copyrightable. But the combination of the pee stick image, the format, the concept of the blog, the clever title, etc., taken altogether, probably is copyrighted. She may have infringed your copyright by using that idea, depending on how many elements in her blog are similar to yours. It would be an interesting fact pattern on a copyright final exam.
Posted by: victoria at Jul 27, 2005 10:22:25 PM
BTW, I also had wisdom teeth removed without the benefit of sedation or adequate novocaine. Six impacted wisdom teeth and hours of unmitigated agony. Now, 22 years later, every time I am approached by a person in a white coat, my legs spasmodically twitch and jerk, as though my body is trying to run out of the room, even though I'm usually able to hold my upper body more or less still.
Oral valium doesn't do it for me, though IV valium does work. But it's hard to find people who'll give you IV valium for a pevlic exam or a teeth cleaning.
Posted by: victoria at Jul 27, 2005 10:28:08 PM
Okay, I'm wondering. Do parents really french kiss their kids? As in stick their tongues in their kids' mouths when kissing? Is this a joke I'm not getting or a cultural thing I'm not aware of? It could be either, honestly, I'm certainly not aware of every cultural variation out there, and different strokes and all that...
or my brain has taken a vacation and the humor is going over my head. Whichever.
Posted by: curious at Jul 27, 2005 10:59:26 PM
In the middle of my sonohystogram my OB turns to me and the two other doctors in the room and says "who do you hate more, your OB or your dentist." Interestingly two of the OBs said very quickly "my OB." Whereas I and my doctor had no hesitation about saying the dentist. It made for a good way to pass the time while getting my innards examined. I was expecting a punch line along the long the lines of "two men walked into a bar..."
I have no genetic gift for good teeth, rather the opposite and I come by my fear quite honestly. I once had bleach pored into my mouth during a root canal by a student dentist. It took them about 30 seconds to understand what "blch, blch im mi mth" meant.
Posted by: Vaughn at Jul 27, 2005 11:03:29 PM
Why couldn't those Scandinavian dental researchers have published these findings a year or two earlier? My job at that time actually involved skimming the dental research journals, and I totally would have sought out xylitol gum when my son was a baby. Now he's 5 and I'm just learning this? Sheesh. Though I haven't had a cavity in years, and my husband has never had one, so maybe the kid will be alright...
Posted by: Orange at Jul 27, 2005 11:57:24 PM
I love your new image!
Posted by: Amy at Jul 28, 2005 1:22:58 AM
My sister works for a prominent chewing gum company so I forwarded on a link to your blog to her. I thought that you might be interested in her response. "Other random things about xylitol - in Cantonese xylitol sounds like sunburnt camel and we had a marketing campaign around the close link!!!"
See, if you didn't have a blog, you'd never find out this kind of fascinating information.
Posted by: Anne at Jul 28, 2005 5:44:51 AM
Love the new graphic. It's great.
Posted by: Andrea at Jul 28, 2005 8:06:53 AM
Love, love, LOVE the new graphic; made me sputter my morning tea on the keyboard! ;-) Love your blog and would love to pinch Charlie's little cheeks (in a good way). Best wishes to all of you from the lurker in the sidelines.
Posted by: Lulu the Lurker at Jul 28, 2005 9:08:46 AM
What a great post! I thought I was the only person who felt the same way about my dentist! When I had my last wisdom tooth removed, he used who knows how many injections - tooth still not numb. He finally used a tool I could swear I last saw liberating a hub cap and the element of surprise to wrench it out. My ears and all of my face, including nose - totally numb, but not the bloody tooth! Thanks for the chuckle - however wry.
Posted by: A at Jul 28, 2005 9:14:56 AM
You're new banner is cracking me up. Especially the little "tink, tink" sound the spermy guy makes as he's trying to penetrate the egg.
Oh, and I hate the dentist too. And have skipped many, many appointments without suffering ill effects. Someday my gums and teeth are going to revolt and I'll pay, but until then, I try like hell to avoid going.
Posted by: Ally at Jul 28, 2005 10:12:04 AM
Oh Julie, I'm a dork. Read much, self? Note to me--read ALL words in the sentence. Flogging commences. Of course the parents chew the gum.
Posted by: Running2Ks at Jul 28, 2005 10:41:23 AM
after reading your blog entry, i was inspired to contact my dentist and was informed that i have not graced their chair since, well... i don't even want to think about it. it is nasty.
so thank you for the important community service you have provided.
LURV the new graphic BTW...
Posted by: tpon at Jul 28, 2005 11:33:49 AM
Lots of gums in the US have xylitol. The sugar-free ones like Orbit et al. (I recommend the dark blue pack of Orbit... I used to be a Trident addict, but Orbit is like Trident x 10).
Posted by: anon at Jul 28, 2005 11:49:26 AM
Hey Julie, I just have to tell you I cackled loudly when I saw your new banner, I love it!
Posted by: Beth at Jul 28, 2005 12:44:31 PM
New reader, but had to post to say:
CHEW THE GUM!!!
I don't know if it works or not, haven't read the articles to see how the evidence stands up--but my DD had 5 cavities at 24 months. We had to do outpatient surgery, under general anesthesia, to get her teeth cleaned and the cavities filled. Surgery was at 9:30, and she couldn't have any food or water b/f coming in. Three hour tantrum w/ a freaked out kid, who just wanted to nurse or have a snap, in a hospital waiting room. Not my idea of fun. In fact, probably the most nerve-wracking experience I've had so far as a mother, since all I could think about were stories about little kids reacting badly to anesthesia.
No one told me before about bacteria, dangers of night-nursing once solids are started, etc.
(I know, I've gotten off lightly if this is my worst story...)
CHEW THE GUM!
Posted by: nate at Jul 28, 2005 5:15:19 PM
Quivering with you at the whole dentist thing. This week in fact. And Pazel too. It's going around.
Posted by: Wavery at Jul 28, 2005 5:23:04 PM
"And the searing epigastric pain of HELLP made me suspect I was pretty darn close to dying."
I didn't realize you had HELLP. I had it with my daughter too. I'd planned for a totally unmedicated birth only to have that "small" complication creep up on me. Gah. Anyway, long story short, my daughter was born the picture of health and that was all I truly could've asked for.
Very interesting about the gum. I'd heard something before about how parents shouldn't bite off pieces of food for their kids because of transferring God knows what to them. Wasn't sure there was any truth to it.
Posted by: Amy at Jul 31, 2005 1:38:30 AM
Hmmm...I had wondered why the Xylitol gum packages here (in Japan) had Sesame Street characters all over them. I may have to pick up a pack at the store tomorrow.
Posted by: Wynnie at Aug 9, 2005 6:56:12 AM

